Comorbidity between enuresis and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder: a case-control study

Abstract

Background

Although there is a strong association between enuresis and psychopathology, little is known about the prevalence of specific psychiatric disorders. We investigate the prevalence of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in children with enuresis and study the impact on child behavior, self-esteem, and different EEG findings. A total number of one hundred 6 to 12 years old children diagnosed as functional enuresis taken from specialized university setting for enuresis at Mansoura Pediatric Outpatient Clinic, in which they could be subdivided into 2 groups after assessment of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD); according to DSM-IV criteria, we also compare them with a third ADHD group taken from Mansoura Psychiatric Outpatient Clinic n = 40 to match the co-morbid “enuresis with ADHD” group. All were subjected to a diagnostic interview conducted and completed with parents and developmental and family history as well, also they subjected to Conner’s parent rating scale-93(CPRS-93), Rosenberg self-esteem assessment scale, and EEG examination.

Results

There was high prevalence of ADHD in our study with about 40% in children with enuresis especially who met the DSM–IV criteria of inattention attending a specialized setting for enuresis at Mansoura Pediatric Outpatient Clinic which is a tertiary setting where the older the children of enuresis, the higher the prevalence of ADHD, also there is a relationship between abnormal epileptiform discharge in EEG finding and enuresis as same as ADHD which became greatly increased in the children who had both disorders who was the most affected group as regard behavioral problems and lowered self-esteem levels.

Conclusions

The strong association between ADHD and enuresis suggests that the presence of enuresis should motivate diagnostic assessment of ADHD especially the inattentive subtype. Abnormal EEG finding in the form of generalized slow and sharp waves may be useful as a predictor for the presence of ADHD in children with enuresis. Also, the co-morbidity increases the negative impact on child behavior and self-esteem.

Background

The most common elimination disorder that affects children is enuresis, which could be defined as per International Children’s Continence Society guidelines as incontinence while asleep in discreet episodes [1].

Etiology of enuresis is complex, it includes genetic, organic, psychological, and behavioral factors [2]. Many authors observed connections between enuresis and sleep where EEG finding shows increased depth of sleep in children with enuresis. Bader noted that children with enuresis had signs of short EEG arousal before enuresis, while Safarinejad found that deep sleep may be the cause [3, 4].

There is an observed association between enuresis and psychopathology in children which is evidenced by an increase of co-morbid behavioral disorders in general and of attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in particular [5, 6]. Studies support the link between enuresis and ADHD where an association between higher scores of ADHD in children having enuresis problems specially inattention [7, 8]. On the other hand, children with ADHD have a higher incidence of enuresis [9].

Enuresis treatment is more difficult in combination with ADHD because of non-compliance. Lloyda B et al. used stimulants where it acts by decreasing sleep arousal threshold thus allowing the child with enuresis to awaken to prevent an enuresis [10].

In this study, we aimed to assess the problem of comorbidity between enuresis and ADHD through analysis of different socio-demographic variables together with associated EEG changes and to study effects of this comorbidity on self-esteem.

Methods

Study design and setting

A case-control study was conducted on children at the Outpatient Clinic of Mansoura Pediatric Hospital in a specialized setting for enuresis treatment every Thursday and Psychiatric Outpatient Clinics from June 2016 till December 2016. A convenient sample of children having functional enuresis who were drug naïve was taken after consent from children and their parents to join the study.

Cases of functional enuresis who met the inclusion criteria were 120, their ages range from 6 to 12 years old, 5 cases refused to enter the study while 15 cases were dropped out during the study due to living at remote areas. On the other hand, cases diagnosed as enuresis who met the inclusion criteria and completed the tools of the study were 100. Both sexes were included, they were divided into 2 groups after assessment of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) according to DSM-IV criteria: first group, enuresis without ADHD n = 60 cases which was referred as enuresis only. This includes patients having functional enuresis with no ADHD symptoms, excluding those who have any ADHD symptoms; second group, enuresis with ADHD n = 40 cases.

Exclusion criteria for both groups who have symptoms suggestive of mental retardation or another psychiatric disorder, or having organic or medical causes of enuresis as DM, spina bifida, diabetes insipidus, congenital anomalies of the bladder, and other organic causes.

A control group consists of 40 children diagnosed as ADHD (was similar to the number of enuresis with ADHD group) who were age and sex matched. They were chosen from children attending the Psychiatric Outpatient Clinic diagnosed as ADHD according to DSM-IV criteria. We excluded children with psychiatric comorbidity or having mental retardation, comorbid enuresis of any cause was also excluded.

Tools

A semi-structured interview to emphasize age, sex, residency, socioeconomic status, home atmosphere, family history, and developmental history was done by interviewing parents.

For all groups, the following were applied:

• A. Assessment of socioeconomic class was assessed by a new scale made by updating and validation of Fahmy and EL-Sherbiny scale [11, 12]. The scale includes 7 domains with a total score of 84, with a lower score indicating lower SES: education, occupation, family, family possessions, economic, home sanitation, and health care. The score was classified into very low, low, middle, and high levels, depending on the quartiles of the calculated score rather than a fixed point.

• B. Complete physical examination

• C. Psychometric assessment using:

• 1- Structured clinical interview for DSM-IV Axis I disorder KID-SCID scale diagnostic interview used to determine DSM-IV Axis I psychiatric disorders in children [13].

• 2- Conner’s parent rating scales (CPRS-93) [14]: Arabic version was used [15].

• 3- The Rosenberg self-esteem scale: To assess self-esteem level in children and adolescents. The scale ranges from 0-30. Scores between 15 and 25 are within normal range; scores below 15 suggest low self-esteem [16]. The Arabic version of the Rosenberg self-esteem scale used in this study was translated and validated through previous research made by Abdel-Khalek and Korayem [17].

• D. Electrophysiological assessment

Electroencephalogram (EEG) examination was carried under standard condition using the 10-20 international electrode placement system, with hyperventilation (continuously for 3 min) and photic stimulation as provocative techniques. This was done to exclude the presence of epilepsy comorbid or as a cause for enuresis.

Statistical analysis

Data were entered into the SPSS for Windows (version 15.0; SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA) and were analyzed using descriptive and analytic analyses including frequencies, mean and standard deviations, percent, t test, and chi-square test for comparison of quantitative and qualitative variables, respectively, F test for comparison of 3 groups, logistic regression analysis was done.

Results

In Table 1, the 3 groups were cross matched regarding all socio-demographic variable except for age, where the 2nd group “enuresis with ADHD” were significantly older with statistical significance P = 0.009*. The family history of enuresis was statistically increased in the first and second groups (with or without ADHD) versus control group P2 = 0.003*, but no statistical difference between both groups of enuresis.

Table 1 Socio-demographic characteristics of the 3 studied groups

Table 2 shows that the group of enuresis with ADHD was more inattentive with a significant statistical difference, while the group of ADHD was more hyperactive (P < 0.001).

Table 2 Distribution of ADHD subtypes in relation to enuresis

Regarding recorded EEG changes and self-esteem assessment as observed in Table 3, in the 1st group, there is a statistical significant increase of focal sharp waves in fronto-temporal region (52.2 %) versus the others. In enuresis with ADHD group, there is a statistical significant increase of generalized slow and sharp waves (39.3%). While in the control group, there is a statistical significant increase of focal sharp waves in the temporal region mainly in the left side (62.5%) versus the other groups. No difference is observed between both groups of enuresis either with or without ADHD as regard self-esteem scores. In enuresis with ADHD group (70.0%) shows low self-esteem with significant statistical difference P3 = 0.01.

Table 3 EEG, self-esteem assessment of the three studied groups

Regarding Table 4, there is a significant statistical difference between the 3 groups regarding most of the subscales of Conner’s except in the restless-disorganized subscale. The enuresis only group, anxious-shy, and psycho-somatic subscales is higher with a mean of 67.5 ± 10.6, while in ADHD group, there is a statistical increase of learning problems subscale with mean of 62.9 ± 12.9.

Table 4 Comparison between Conners’ parent rating scale (CPRS-93) of the 3 studied groups

Table 5 shows the results of logistic regression where EEG abnormality specially generalized waves was the only predictor for presence of ADHD in children with enuresis.

Table 5 Stepwise Logistic regression analysis of risk factors between enuresis only group and enuresis with ADHD group

Discussion

In our study, we traced the association between enuresis and ADHD in children from 6 to 12 years taken from Mansoura University Pediatric and Psychiatric Outpatient Clinic. The number of cases complaining of enuresis was 100, 40 of them were found to have symptoms of ADHD with a prevalence rate of 40%. This high rate of ADHD in our study because most resistant and problematic cases are usually referred to university hospitals, which is a tertiary care unite. This was very similar to the previous conducted studies [2, 8]. They explained that the association between both enuresis and inattentive ADHD subtype may be due to a deficits in arousal. Other studies reported that the rate ranges from 10 to 20%, which may be due to differences in the sampling method or due to different age groups [18, 19].

Our data also revealed that the older the children, the higher the prevalence of the ADHD, this finding reflects the potential importance of ADHD as a comorbidity factor in a therapy resistant population and indicate the importance of screening and early treatment of ADHD. This was similar to a study made by Bayens who found the maximal prevalence of enuresis at age of 8 years, followed by a decline to age 11 years which was consistent with the findings that the older the children, the higher the prevalence of the ADHD [5].

By studying gender disparity between the groups in our study, there was a male predominance with about 2:1 male to female ratio. This data is in concordance with a study of Tai HL, Sheerman [6, 20]. Where ADHD is similar to enuresis, as in each disorder, boys are generally more often than girls. Thus, the chance for boys having enuresis to have increased behavioral problems is twice as high as for girls with enuresis. This was similar to an epidemiological study in Moroccan children [21].

Socio-economic level revealed that most of children of the 3 groups had mainly very low or low scores, as they were coming mostly from rural areas. This was similar to a study of Beiderman J who reported that enuresis is strongly associated with social disadvantage, as psychopathology such as ADHD [22]. It has been postulated that socioeconomic status (SES) is a common underlying factor by which behavioral problems and enuresis emerge simultaneously [23].

Other risk factors of enuresis include family history of enuresis which is similar to studies of Bayoumi RA and Wang QW [24, 25]. Considering the family history of enuresis in a study by Ismail et al., more than fifty of children of enuresis had a positive family history, which was explained by presence of genetic factor in occurrence of enuresis; however, this result was slightly higher than our study, as family history involved only the first-degree relatives [18].

EEG (electro-encephalography) was done to confirm the underlying pathology in each group. Enuresis with ADHD group had an association between EEG abnormalities with a family history of enuresis, in which generalized slow and sharp waves in EEG finding is statistically significant. These were found to be a predictor for presence of co-morbid ADHD diagnosis in children with enuresis by logistic regression analysis.

Enuresis only group showed high incidence of focal slow or sharp waves in fronto-temporal region, while focal sharp waves in the temporal region were found mostly in the ADHD control group, these findings were mainly on the left side. These results were supported by a study, which found that most cases of children who presented with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, enuresis, and breath-holding spells had abnormal generalized or focal sharp waves predominantly in the left hemisphere in most patients [26]. This suggests that epileptiform activity in non-epileptic children might reflect age-dependent mechanisms of brain dysfunction. It is possible that global CNS maturation delay may be a contributor to enuresis. This was proved by Hunsballe JM, who noticed that progressive maturation of bladder stability occurs in conjunction with EEG findings suggest increased CNS recognition of bladder fullness and the ability to suppress the onset of bladder contraction, which improves with increasing of age [27]. The same was reported in study by Hashem S, while it was contradicted by study of Morohongo et al. who found that only half of the children with ADHD had abnormal epileptiform discharges in EEG findings [28, 29].

It was found that the co-morbidity between enuresis and ADHD worsen the self-esteem level, although there was no statistical difference between both groups of enuresis which means that enuresis had its own negative impact on self-esteem regardless of the ADHD diagnosis. This was supported by a previous study of Mellon MW et al. [9].

Regarding the impact of enuresis and ADHD on children’s behavior, “enuresis only” group showed only a significant increase in anxious-shy and psycho-somatic subscales, which can be explained by feeling of shame due to fear from being discovered by others, which makes the child distressed and shy. While in the control ADHD group, there is a statistical increase of learning disability. This could be explained by presence of ADHD diagnosis, in which the core symptoms of inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity have a direct negative impact on the learning process.

In this study, it was clear that enuresis with ADHD showed higher levels of behavioral problems and lower levels in self-esteem scores.

Conclusions

• Prevalence of ADHD in a child having enuresis reached about 40% which requires careful assessment and management of the symptoms of ADHD that rarely receive treatment. The presence of enuresis in a child causes a psychological and social embarrassment leading to low self-esteem and behavioral problems on rating scales. While the association between enuresis and EEG changes in a child can predict the presence of comorbid ADHD.

  We recommend the following:

• Further developmental, genetic, and family studies are recommended to verify the link between both disorders.

• Quantitative EEG techniques or sleep EEG assessment to illustrate the relationship between sleep disorders or arousal problems and enuresis as well as ADHD.

• Assessment of ADHD should routinely include evaluation for enuresis and vice versa through collaboration between psychiatrists, pediatric health care professionals, general practitioners, and school mental health team together with parents aiming at achieving better health care.

Limitations

Our study did not give a specific explanation for enuresis and ADHD through EEG but it could give an idea about association of enuresis with ADHD and different EEG findings. Also, a small number of the sample would limit the generalizability of the results, thus including higher number of subjects would increase statistical power.